Ruby KissesWaterproof Eyeliner, 24HR Waterproof Long-Lasting Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil with Built-in Sharpener, Smudgeproof 3 Pack (Blackest Black)

I wanted really waterproof makeup for my trip to Florida, where we would be on the beach, in the ocean and exposed to much more humidity than we are used to up north. This eyeliner didn't disappoint! I played in the ocean, and I forgot to clean off my makeup a couple of evenings, and it stayed in place, it doesn't smear, and, best of all, it goes on nice and smooth! I wish it came in a lighter brown, but that's the only complaint I have!

These are the best cheap mechanical eyeliners I've been able to find in a long time. I'm broke asf so I have to stick to cheap makeup and I'm very happy with these. It lasts all day and are fairly run resistant. They don't give you raccoon eyes, I don't really have to wipe the eyeliner from under my eyes. You know, when you have to put your finger or tissue under your bottom lashes and wipe upwards. Yeah I don't find myself having to do that. If you make a mistake though it's kinda hard to wipe it to correct it, but at the same time that's good because it makes it stay on all day. I'll definitely buy these again.

Water proof… long lasting

I am very happy with these waterproof eyeliners. I got the 4 pack that had black, black/brown, brown and white in it. I love them. I find them easy to put on. They glide on easily with others I had they were often dry and felt more like a kind of torture. Which this is a really nice switch …the colors are rich. They are waterproof and I have had no issues with them smudging throughout the day which was always an issue for me. I would look like a panda by the end of the day with other brands. The one time I didn’t take it off before bed it did smudge (obviously)…but it still didn’t look terrible.All in all I am very happy with this product

I always order these. I use them to tight line & they work great.

I bought this due to good reviews and all the people who said this eyeliner stays on for hours and hours. I know this is inexpensive, but it smudged and/or evaporated from my skin within 2 hours of applying it. I tend to have a bit of oily skin under my eyes, but still. I put it on in the early morning before work, and by the time I got to work 1.5 hours later, it looked like I hadn't even put on any eyeliner. It was a waste of my money.

I have been looking for an eyeliner that will still look good after teaching for eight hours and this is the one! It doesn’t smudge on my face as I am bad about touching my eyes a lot, I don’t have to touch it up, and when I get home at the end of the day I’m not appalled by what I see in the mirror haha!

This product does not put out as it says. You have to press hard under the eye area to receive anythingthat looks like a line.I have tried many liners and this one fails to perform. You can't always believe whatthe packaging says. This one did not deliver for me. Yes, the price is affordable but I prefer paying morefor a liner that does what you want it to do.