Benefit Cosmetics They're Real Push-Up Liner - Beyond Blue - 100% Authentic

Very dry not easy to apply.. Put it in the bin

I have this liner in black, purple, and brown because it is easy to apply, smooth, and long lasting. This blue, from this seller, has dried up/denatured or is not the actual Benefit formula but something else added to the completely legitimate packaging. I should have listened to the other two reviewers who said this was dry, clumpy and impossible. I could’ve gotten a better product from a drugstore for a third of the price. This doesn’t even go on evenly and you cannot correct it because making another pass just randomly wipes off some of the product. This is not worth it at any price though normally this liner would be one of the best on the market.

Color is okay but it comes out all clumped up and is nearly impossible to apply in a straight line

I didn't like at all, I try to use it but while I open it come out and fall down. I do this many time and still the same the texture is not good and broken eyeliner material

Terrible eye liner I prefer a thin line this applicator was odd